To take part in discussions on talkSFU, please apply for membership (SFU email id required).

confused about my feelings for my friend

edited August 2007 in General
ok, so here's my situation. i've been friends with this person for about 6 years and we're very close. when either one of us needs help, we call on each other. we've never been in a relationship together, only on a friendly basis. over the past year, my friend was in a relationship but recently broke up. Oddly, I felt relieved--even happy--about the breakup because I guess I was a little jealous, even though as a friend, I shouldn't feel that way. I'm a little confused that maybe I have feelings for my friend that I never realized I had because in retrospect, i wouldn't be jealous of the relationship if i didn't want something to happen between us instead, right?

and if I do want a relationship, how do I know that my friend feels the same way as I do, without explicitly asking?? It's difficult for me to get any tell-tale signs since we're very close already and we're touchy-feely anyway.

but say we both feel the same way about each other, do I even want to put our friendship at risk? I think it's too idealistic to believe that we could be friends again if our relationship didn't work out--there's always the chance that it doesn't, even if it's a small chance, and I don't know if i want to take that risk.

What are your guys' thoughts? Am I love-sick? Should I do anything about it?

Comments

  • edited August 2007
    Do you see this other person more like a brother/sister? If you can't picture yourself kissing, making out etc with this friend.. then you probably think of this friend more like a brother/sister.

    Have you considered that perhaps you feel jealous because you & your friend are really tight & this g/f or b/f took your friend's time away from you? So perhaps, its not so much that you want a relationship, but just wanted to spend time with your friend?

    I would wait awhile to see if the feelings subside, but if you are still unsure of your feelings, I really think that you should talk to your friend about your feelings. You been friends for 6 years and are very close. I assume your friend will be very sensitive towards your feelings, and would let you know his/her thoughts & feelings. If your friend is not interested, he/she will let you know, and you guys will remain friends. If your friend is interested, then I assume you guys will discuss the situation. It's really hard to say what/what not to do. And no one can say if things would work out. But I do know that the best relationships are built on friendship & communication, which you have with your friend. Hope things work out.
  • edited August 2007
    lol i've had that feeling before.. i just couldn't tell as well >>, if u do like her, why not just give a bump or two to see how they react,
  • edited August 2007
    Thats a tough one. From my experience watching Friends, I would say that you should talk to her about it in a mature yet non-serious way (kinda like when Joey starts liking Rachel even though they've been friends for so long). This way, you can both get your feelings out in the open, and even if things are awkward at first, it will be better in the long run. If your friend doesn't share your affection, they will tell you and it will help you get rid of the crush you have. If you keep your crush bottled up inside it will keep creating questions in your mind that will distract you from things, and even affect your friendship with her. So if your friendship is going to be affected either way, just talk about it!
  • edited August 2007
    Just don't cross the nice guy line... I don't have to explain why do I...
  • edited August 2007
    hehe (un)fortunately, I don't have a penis.
    but I can see why it was so confusing because after reading my post I realized I didn't even mention that my friend is a guy or that I'm a girl. How odd, I don't know how I managed to do that...but anyway...
    Have you considered that perhaps you feel jealous because you & your friend are really tight & this g/f or b/f took your friend's time away from you? So perhaps, its not so much that you want a relationship, but just wanted to spend time with your friend?
    This is a really good point. I was spending less time with him when he was in a relationship and I guess that was an uncomfortable change for me, but we were still close and he was still able to make more than enough time for me. I'm not usually a jealous type either so even though it's hard to distinguish what exactly these feelings are, I still think I have some underlying crush on him.

    I'll wait for my feelings to calm down a little bit though. It could be hormonal thing (us girls, eh? ;) )

    btw, you guys give really good advice, much better than the guys I know :)
  • edited August 2007
    ehe (un)fortunately, I don't have a penis.
    :o DUDE WHAT HAPPENED?
  • edited August 2007
    Morro;15371 said:
    :o DUDE WHAT HAPPENED?
    lawlz....>> that was a horrible comment =P?
  • edited August 2007
    meesh;15367 said:
    hehe (un)fortunately, I don't have a penis.
    I dont have one either!! I do find them interesting tho, lolol!
  • edited August 2007
    lol :o

    in honour of magnificent bastard, i think he was the one to say this on the other post,

    just whip it out!
  • edited August 2007
    hahaha you guys are hilarious.

    well, innovations these days would allow me to have a fake one =P. don't know how effective that would be for my situation...

    haha this thread could really go R-rated
  • edited August 2007
    just whip it out =P
  • edited August 2007
    I was thinking exactly that imelting
  • edited August 2007
    meesh;15367 said:
    hehe (un)fortunately, I don't have a penis.
    Isn't it Freud who said that women have penis envy?? HAha .....I'm a girl & that ain't true for me.
  • edited August 2007
    hmm.. well since you know him for 6 years... how do you think he'll react if you told him that? will he freak out? and would it jeopardize the friendship? I'm asking this because the post seems to say you value this friendship.. and 6 years is not a small number so to speak..

    I would suggest not to say/do anything.. especially after his recent breakup it's really not the right time to dish out something like that.. if it's not seriously driving you insane.. why not wait it out a little.. see if it's just really the hormonal changes or if you honestly have feelings for him... after all.. it would be best for both you and him to get a little time out.. =)

    to be honest this is a toughie and I say that from personal experience.. I lost 3 guys friends (2 of them who were quite close to me) after I rejected their advances.. it just seems that once the boy-girl relationship factors in.. the friendship can never be quite the same again.. and I think that's something you should be aware and prepared for if you do decide to tell him.. and I can't help but wonder... it really that hard to just be friends if a relationship doesn't work out?
  • edited August 2007
    Smiles;15391 said:
    Isn't it Freud who said that women have penis envy?? HAha .....I'm a girl & that ain't true for me.
    haha that isn't true for me either. i'm happy with what i got, thank you very much Freud.
  • edited August 2007
    siuying;15392 said:

    to be honest this is a toughie and I say that from personal experience.. I lost 3 guys friends (2 of them who were quite close to me) after I rejected their advances.. it just seems that once the boy-girl relationship factors in.. the friendship can never be quite the same again.. and I think that's something you should be aware and prepared for if you do decide to tell him.. and I can't help but wonder... it really that hard to just be friends if a relationship doesn't work out?
    if you don't mind me asking, seeing as how you have been in this situation but on the opposite end, what were some reasons why you rejected your guy friends? I just want to get a picture of what might go through his head IF I told him (or if I "whipped it out" haha)
  • edited August 2007
    imelting;15381 said:
    lol :o

    in honour of magnificent bastard, i think he was the one to say this on the other post,

    just whip it out!
    I just noticed this. I believe it is a sound solution to any of life's problems.
  • edited August 2007
    meesh;15431 said:
    if you don't mind me asking, seeing as how you have been in this situation but on the opposite end, what were some reasons why you rejected your guy friends? I just want to get a picture of what might go through his head IF I told him (or if I "whipped it out" haha)
    not at all meesh.. =) i guess it's because i draw a distinct line between friends and potential bfs.. the question of starting a relationship never really crossed my mind with them because they're like my buddies.. and it just doesn't feel right to suddenly change that friendship to a boy-girl relationship.. =\ but my situation is different from yours.. i never harboured any feelings for these guys and was totally clueless about their intentions.. @_@ then again.. you're talking from a female brain here.. =P

Leave a Comment